Louise Chudleigh

Louise is recognised in the legal directories as a leading junior in employment law. Louise has significant experience in multi-party equal pay litigation and has experience of complex discrimination claims. She enjoys, and is skilled at preparing and presenting lengthy, fact rich, document heavy first instance employment cases and also has an appellate practice.

She regularly acts on behalf of local authorities, NHS Trusts, police services, financial institutions and other large employers in complex discrimination cases and has represented several local authorities, NHS Trusts and private sector employers in large multi-party equal pay. She has been instructed in the Birmingham City Council equal pay litigation (reputed to be the largest ever equal pay case) since 2007, and more recently for a large supermarket in an ongoing equal pay litigation.

Louise acts regularly on behalf of employees and trade unions. She has particular expertise in matters relating to the employment and dismissal of medical practitioners and is instructed regularly by both NHS Trusts and doctors.

A selection of recent cases

Equal Pay

Ongoing equal pay claims against a large supermarket. Recent appearances include EAT hearings in relation to a dispute about the validity of a job evaluation scheme, comparator disclosure ([2021] 1 WLUK 474) and a stay. The case is listed for a multi week employment tribunal hearing in 2023;

Birmingham City Council equal pay litigation which has included a 5-week GMF hearing and multiple other appearances in the tribunal, EAT, CA and the Supreme Court (in Abdulla & others [2013] IRLR 38);

Many other multiple and individual claims in both the private and public sector organisations.

Discrimination

• Smo v Hywel DDA University Health Board [2022] – a complex employment tribunal claim for direct race discrimination, victimisation, unfair dismissal and wrongful dismissal in which Louise acted for the respondent against leading counsel and succeeded on all issues, including establishing that a complaint of race discrimination was made in bad faith;
• Shittu v South London & Maudsley NHS Foundation Trust [2022] IRLR 382]– disability discrimination and other matters (EAT);
• The Commissioner of the City of London Police v Geldart [2021] I.C.R. 1329 – sex/maternity discrimination (CA);
• X v a firm [2019] – complex associative discrimination claim involving a vulnerable witness;
• Dahou v Serco Ltd – trade union dismissal claim – went to the Court of Appeal via the EAT and was remitted to the tribunal;
• Kudrath v National Policing Improvement Agency – 5-week ET case about sex and race discrimination. Acted for the Respondent and succeeded in relation to all 62 allegations.

Injunctions

• Jain v Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust;
• Elangovan v The Pennine Acute Hospitals NHS Trust;
• Fynes v St Georges Healthcare NHS Trust [2014] All ER (D) 210 (Mar) – claim for an injunction to restrain a Trust for pursuing conduct proceedings;
• West London Mental Health Trust v Dr Chhabra [2013] IRLR 398 – CA case about injunctive relief so as to restrain proposed disciplinary proceedings;
• Kulkarni v Milton Keynes Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust [2009] IRLR 829 – Louise obtained the initial HC injunction in this case;
• WRN Ltd v Ayris [2008] IRLR 889, a case involving the enforcement of restrictive covenants.

Louise has practiced in the field of employment law for a significant time and has been a fee-paid employment judge since 2001. She has extensive experience of conducting all types of investigations as well as presiding over both disciplinary and grievance proceedings.

Feedback from clients has included:

• “Many thanks for your report – it’s exactly what’s required.”
• “Thank you very much Louise for being so thorough and diligent throughout”.

Recent examples of Louise’s work in this area include:

• ​A confidential investigation into sensitive matters for a national sporting body.
• Conducting a sensitive investigation for a local authority into allegations of serious sexual assault.
• Investigating allegations of fraud for a medical supplies company.
• Chairing a disciplinary appeal following a dismissal for historic sexual harassment.
• Investigating allegations of sexual misconduct outside the workplace.
• Determining an internal workplace grievance and making recommendations.
• Conducting a fact-finding investigation into allegations of race discrimination for the purposes of a grievance appeal by woman employed in a global engineering company.

Louise Chudleigh’s practice has encompassed matters relating to the disciplining and dismissing of doctors, dentists, other health-care professionals and the police for over 20 years.

Louise has frequently appeared in medical employment cases in the employment tribunal, in the High Court and on appeal, including in the Supreme Court in Chhabra v West London Mental Health NHS Trust. She sits as a legal adviser to NHS disciplinary panels and also acts as an advocate in disciplinary hearings. Louise has appeared before the GMC and the HPC and other regulatory bodies, and has acted as a legal assessor for the British Psychological Society’s Conduct and Fitness to Practice Committees.

A sample of cases in which Louise has appeared includes:

• Dr X v NHS Trust Y [2019] – attempt to halt disciplinary process;
• Jain v Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust [2018] – injunction relating to a proposed a SOSR disciplinary hearing;
• Elangovan v The Pennine Acute Hospitals NHS Trust [2018] – case involving misconduct and SOSR;
• Dowsing v Shrewsbury & Telford NHS Trust [2016] – successfully acted for consultant orthodontist in case concerning whistleblowing about breach of waiting list referral to treatment times;
• Re Dr A [2016] – appeared for consultant cardiothoracic surgeon in matters relating to alleged misconduct;
• Ni’Man v Norfolk Community Healthcare NHS Trust [2016] – instructed in internal disciplinary hearings and employment tribunal in long running dispute regarding alleged misconduct by an associate specialist;
• Re Dr B [2015] – acted for practitioner before GMC in issues related to fitness to practice;
• Fynes v St George’s Hospital NHS Trust [2014] EWHC 756 (QB) – HC decision concerning classification of disciplinary allegations as between conduct and health;
• Chhabra v West London Mental Health NHS Trust [2014] IRLR 22 – SC decision about injunctive relief in relation to disciplinary proceedings.

Louise Chudleigh’s practice has encompassed matters relating to the disciplining and dismissing of doctors, dentists, other health-care professionals and the police for over 20 years.

Louise has frequently appeared in medical employment cases in the employment tribunal, in the High Court and on appeal, including in the Supreme Court in Chhabra v West London Mental Health NHS Trust. She sits as a legal adviser to NHS disciplinary panels and also acts as an advocate in disciplinary hearings. Louise has appeared before the GMC and the HPC and other regulatory bodies, and has acted as a legal assessor for the British Psychological Society’s Conduct and Fitness to Practice Committees.

A sample of cases in which Louise has appeared includes:

• NHS Trust v Dr X [2021] – internal disciplinary hearing against a doctor accused of very serious sexual assault. Louise acted for the Trust at the initial hearing and then (against leading counsel) at the appeal;
• Dr X v NHS Trust Y [2019] – attempt to halt disciplinary process;
• Jain v Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust [2018] – injunction relating to a proposed a SOSR disciplinary hearing;
• Elangovan v The Pennine Acute Hospitals NHS Trust [2018] – case involving misconduct and SOSR;
• Dowsing v Shrewsbury & Telford NHS Trust [2016] – successfully acted for consultant orthodontist in case concerning whistleblowing about breach of waiting list referral to treatment times;
• Re Dr A [2016] – appeared for consultant cardiothoracic surgeon in matters relating to alleged misconduct;
• Ni’Man v Norfolk Community Healthcare NHS Trust [2016] – instructed in internal disciplinary hearings and employment tribunal in long running dispute regarding alleged misconduct by an associate specialist;
• Re Dr B [2015] – acted for practitioner before GMC in issues related to fitness to practice;
• Fynes v St George’s Hospital NHS Trust [2014] EWHC 756 (QB) – HC decision concerning classification of disciplinary allegations as between conduct and health;
• Chhabra v West London Mental Health NHS Trust [2014] IRLR 22 – SC decision about injunctive relief in relation to disciplinary proceedings.

• Lichters v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis;
• Serco v Dahou;
• Sefton Borough Council v Wainwright [2015] I.C.R. 652: Claimant’s post deleted while on maternity leave — Claimant interviewed but failed to obtain suitable new post — When obligation to offer suitable vacancy arising —Whether maternity discrimination under Equality Act 2010 s 18;
• Serco Ltd v Dahou [2015] I.R.L.R. 30: trade union activities case about the burden of proof in detriment and automatic unfair dismissal claims. Court of appeal hearing pending;
• Thomson v Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, Employment Appeal Tribunal, 30 January 2015: Disability discrimination and unfair dismissal case regarding reasonable adjustments, Polkey and range of reasonable responses;
• Fynes v St George’s Hospital NHS Trust [2014] EWHC 756 (QB), [2014] All ER (D) 210 (Mar): HC decision concerning classification of disciplinary allegations as between conduct and health;
• Bashford v NFU [2014]: ET case concerning victimisation and unfair dismissal. Acted for Claimant and succeeded in both claims;
• Dr Chhabra v West London Mental Health NHS Trust [2014] IRLR 22: SC decision about injunctive relief in relation to disciplinary proceedings;
• West London Mental Health Trust v Chhabra [2013] IRLR 398: CA case about injunctive relief so as to restrain proposed disciplinary proceedings. SC decision awaited;
• Dahou v Serco Ltd [2013]: complex ET claim in which the ET was successfully persuaded to find that the dismissal of a trade union representative was for union related reasons;
• Birmingham City Council v Abdulla & others, SC [2013] IRLR 38: SC decision about the right to bring equal pay claims in the common law courts;
• Thompson v Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust [2013]: ET case about whether there had been a failure to make reasonable adjustments in relation to a doctor who was dismissed from gross misconduct;
• Peat v Birmingham City Council [2012] All ER (D) 178: EAT decision successfully defending a large award of costs by an ET;
• Beddoes and others v Birmingham City Council [2011] 3 CMLR 1151: EAT case about various issues related to equal pay claims;
• Sefton Metropolitan Borough Council & Sefton New Directions v Hincks and others [2011] ICR 1357;
• Ashby and ors v Birmingham City Council [2011] EWHC 424: HC equal pay claim;
• BCC v Akhtar [2012] EWCA Civ 585, [2012] All ER (D) 28: CA case concerning dispute resolution procedures.

• Quantification of consequential loss in cases of constructive dismissal
• Commissioner of the City of London Police v Claire Geldart [2021] EWCA Civ 611 – Case summary by Emily Skinner
• The Commissioners of the City of London Police v Geldart UKEAT/0032/19/RN
• High Court judgment in the case of Dr. Anil Kumar Jain v Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust